Click on our Secret Library of Evidence ------>

    BANKILEAKS Secret Library

Loan Application Forms (LAF's)  

    Bank Emails to Brokers  

    Then Click on 'VIEW NOTEBOOK'

Join us on facebook

facebook3           facebook2 


What BFCSA Does...

BFCSA investigates fraud involving lenders, spruikers and financial planners worldwide.  Full Doc, Low Doc, No Doc loans, Lines of Credit and Buffer loans appear to be normal profit making financial products, however, these loans are set to implode within seven years.  For the past two decades, Ms Brailey, President of BFCSA (Inc), has been a tireless campaigner, championing the cause of older and low income people around the Globe who have fallen victim to banking and finance scams.  She has found that people of all ages are being targeted by Bankers offering faulty lending products. BFCSA warn that anyone who has signed up for one of these financial products, is in grave danger of losing their home.


Articles View Hits

Whistleblowers' Corner!

To all mortgage brokers, BDMs and loan approval officers! 
Pls Call Denise: 0401 642 344 

"Confidentiality is assured."

Cartoon Corner

Lighten your load today and "Laugh all the way to the bank!"

Lee Doyle

Led by award-winning consumer advocate Denise Brailey, BFCSA (Inc) are a group of people who are concerned about the appalling growth of Loan Fraud around the world. BFCSA (Inc) is a not for profit organisation in the spirit of global community concern and justice.

Click on the Cluster Map.

  • Home
    Home This is where you can find all the blog posts throughout the site.
  • Categories
    Categories Displays a list of categories from this blog.
  • Bloggers
    Bloggers Search for your favorite blogger from this site.
  • Login
    Login Login form

Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd v CTC Group [2012] NSWCA 252

Posted by on in From My Window
  • Font size: Larger Smaller
  • Hits: 1750
  • Print -


Subjects: Broker liability, Damages awarded to lenders, Fraud, Origination, Proportionate Liability, Identification

CTC (as originator), submitted to Resimac (as manager), a forged application for a loan by Perpetual (as trustee) of $480,000. As required under the mortgage origination deed CTC verified the identity of the applicant, Mr David El-Bayeh.

The loan was made and upon default proceedings were commenced for possession of the property. The trial judge accepted Mr El-Bayeh’s denials that he signed the documents and found his signatures on the loan application, loan agreement and mortgage had been forged. The judge determined that Mr El-Bayeh's brother Mr Youssef El-Bayeh had forged his brother's signatures (click here for our case note). This resulted in a total loss of the funds advanced.

Perpetual sued CTC, alleging it had breached terms of the mortgage origination deed by failing to take reasonable care to identify the proposed borrower. The trial judge rejected this claim, and Perpetual appealed. The court of appeal reversed the trial judge and found against the originator.

The trial judge held that this conversation took place. Nevertheless found for CTC commenting:

"In light of the undisputed fact that CTC obtained a photocopy of David El-Bayeh's passport, the possibility remains that a family member with a resemblance to David El-Bayeh impersonated him. It follows that I am not satisfied that there was any breach of duty on the part of CTC ... "

The Court of Appeal disagreed:

The primary judge's unchallenged findings were that Mr David El-Bayeh did not sign the application. If CTC did not make the requisite comparison between the signatory of the application and the original passport photograph, he failed to act with reasonable care. The fact that the application was submitted despite Mr David El-Bayeh not having signed it, strongly suggests that it did not.

In my view the strong probabilities are that Mr Naaman did not compare the original passport photograph with anyone who falsely purported to be Mr David El-Bayeh because, if he had, he would have observed that the photograph was not of the person before him. The possibility that someone could have successfully impersonated Mr El-Bayeh whilst Mr Naaman was carefully comparing the passport photograph to him is in my view remote.

The lesson from this case is clear. Those identifying borrowers, whether brokers, or originators, or solicitors, must view the original identification documents (passport or drivers licence) at the same time as they view the borrower in person. If they fail to realise they are looking at an imposter they will be disbelieved by the Court who will consider that such failure is unlikely to be the true explanation of the fraud slipping through and it is more likely that they never properly ID the borrower.

Last modified on
Rate this blog entry:


  • doyla66
    doyla66 Sunday, 21 October 2012

    The lenders will go to any lengths to get loans on their books.

  • doyla66
    doyla66 Sunday, 21 October 2012

    Borrowers often don't meet the lender or the broker. Everything is sent in via fax or set up online. The lender's objective is to get pre-approval asap and get the borrower signed up.
    And that's before they bring in the online application and totally automated system wrt title deeds etc.
    It's "get them on the loan books as quick as."

Leave your comment

Guest Saturday, 05 December 2020